Unmasking Luca: A Dating App Deception That Shocked New York

In the digital age, dating apps have become a staple for singles looking for love. However, not every profile is as genuine as it appears. This is the story of Danielle, who thought she had met her perfect match on Hinge, only to discover a tangled web of deception spanning multiple women across the country. This cautionary tale highlights the red flags of online dating and how to protect yourself from manipulative partners.

Meeting Luca: A Seemingly Perfect Match
Danielle, a successful New Yorker, was seeking a meaningful connection. When she met Luca on Hinge, everything seemed to align perfectly. A tenured professor at two prestigious universities, Luca appeared to be the ideal catch—intelligent, charming, and future-focused. Their first date was straight out of a romance novel, filled with laughter, deep conversations, and plans for future outings, including a Halloween party in matching costumes.

Early Signs of Trouble: The Subtle Red Flags
At first, everything seemed too good to be true. Luca was attentive, communicative, and planned thoughtful dates. However, small inconsistencies began to emerge:

• Disappearing for days with vague excuses

• Avoiding FaceTime calls

• Traveling under dubious circumstances

• Over-the-top declarations of exclusivity early on

Despite these warning signs, Danielle, like many hopeful romantics, gave him the benefit of the doubt.

The Big Lie: Faking a Trip to Italy
Luca told Danielle that he had to travel to Italy to care for his injured mother. He sent carefully timed texts and calls to make his story seem believable. However, when Danielle and other women he was dating compared notes, they discovered he had never left the country. Instead, he was juggling multiple women simultaneously, feeding each of them the same fabricated stories.

The Power of Online Communities: How the Truth Came Out
Danielle’s discovery of Luca’s lies came through the "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" app, a platform where women share their experiences and verify potential red flags. Multiple women reported exclusive relationships with Luca, confirming that he was a serial dater using the same script on different women.

Lessons Learned: How to Protect Yourself from Dating App Scammers

1. Trust but Verify – If someone’s story seems too perfect, do a little research. Google their name, check social media, and look for inconsistencies.

2. Use Online Resources – Platforms like "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" and "The Tea App" can provide valuable insights into a person’s dating history.

3. Pay Attention to Red Flags – Love bombing, avoiding FaceTime, and frequent travel excuses are all signs of potential deception.

4. Control the Pace – Even if someone is pushing for exclusivity, take your time before committing.

5. Document Your Experience – Keeping notes on your dating journey can help you spot patterns and make informed decisions.

Final Thoughts Luca’s story is a stark reminder that not everyone on dating apps has genuine intentions. While technology has made dating more accessible, it has also enabled deceitful individuals to operate with ease. By staying informed, trusting your instincts, and leveraging online tools, you can safeguard your heart—and your time—from those who seek to manipulate others.

Have you ever encountered a dating app scammer? Share your experience in the comments below!

If you love dating scam stories, don't forget to listen to Ex-Wives Undercover - the best podcast, with multiple seasons of the craziest love gone wrong stories!